An effort to differentiate 'Mamsagat-vata' & 'Mamsavrutta-vat based on Ch.Chi.28 Sr. No. VIBHEDAKATVA MAMSAGATA VATA MAMSAVRUT VATA 1. VYADHITVA Mamasagata Vata is a degenerative condition of Mamsa dhatu mentioned in Charak Samhita Vtavyadhi Chikitsa. Mamsavrut Vata is a Santarpanjanita condition where increased Vikrita-Mamsa dhatu obstructs the path of Vata dosha. 2. NIDANA As per Vatavyadhi Not mentioned specifically but as per general principal, Santarpan & Dhatu-dushti   causes may be considered. 3. PURVARUPA None as per Vatavyadhi               None being Vatavyadhi but clinically increased/ overnutrition of Vaikrita Mamsa dhatu would be observed because it obstructs the path of Vata dosha, leading to signs and symptoms. 4.       INTRODUCTION : Why ‘Mamsa-medogata Vat

 An effort to differentiate 'RAKTAGAT-VAT' & RAKTAVRUTTA-VAT' as per Ch.Chi.-28. Sr. No VIBHEDAKATVA RAKTAGATA VATA RAKTAAVRUTA VATA 1. VYADHITVA These both conditions are Vishistha Avastha as per Vatavyadhi & not been established as vyadhi. 2. REFERENCE SHLOKA रुजस्तीव्राः ससन्तापा वैवर्ण्यं कृशताऽरुचिः | गात्रे चारूंषि भुक्तस्य स्तम्भश्चासृग्गतेऽनिले ||Ch.Chi.-28 रक्तावृते सदाहार्तिस्त्वङ्मांसान्तरजो भृशम् || ६३ || भवेत् सरागः श्वयथुर्जायन्ते मण्डलानि च | Ch.Chi.-28 3. NIDANA As per Vatavyadhi: As per Vatarakta: 4. Purvaroop None as per Vatavyadhi As per Vatarakta: 4. SHLEHSMA STHITI Shleshmaguna Kshaya is present because of vata-prakop & Dhatu Kshaya condition. Shleshmaguna kshaya is usually not present.